DONE QoL Improvements for the Guides Section

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 2, 2025
Messages
30
Reaction Score
99
Shards
Shards 127
Writing the second entry in my OPSEC series ran into a wall fairly quickly — the 10,000 character limit. For a reference guide covering a topic in any real depth, that's tight. I had to cut content that genuinely belonged in the post just to fit, which works against the whole point of a guides section.

Three things that would make a meaningful difference:

  • Raise or remove the character limit for the Guides section — 10k is workable for a short post, but guides tend to be longer by nature. A limit of 20–25k, or none at all, would give writers the room to actually cover a topic properly without having to strip it down.
  • Remove the 5-minute edit restriction — Guides aren't static. They get corrected, expanded, and updated as feedback comes in or information changes. A hard edit window makes it needlessly difficult to maintain quality over time, which is the opposite of what a guides section should encourage.
  • Add a version history or edit log — Readers benefit from knowing when a guide was last updated and what changed. Even a simple changelog at the bottom of a post would help establish trust and signal that the content is actively maintained.

Thank you in advance.


 
Writing the second entry in my OPSEC series ran into a wall fairly quickly — the 10,000 character limit. For a reference guide covering a topic in any real depth, that's tight. I had to cut content that genuinely belonged in the post just to fit, which works against the whole point of a guides section.

Three things that would make a meaningful difference:

  • Raise or remove the character limit for the Guides section — 10k is workable for a short post, but guides tend to be longer by nature. A limit of 20–25k, or none at all, would give writers the room to actually cover a topic properly without having to strip it down.
  • Remove the 5-minute edit restriction — Guides aren't static. They get corrected, expanded, and updated as feedback comes in or information changes. A hard edit window makes it needlessly difficult to maintain quality over time, which is the opposite of what a guides section should encourage.
  • Add a version history or edit log — Readers benefit from knowing when a guide was last updated and what changed. Even a simple changelog at the bottom of a post would help establish trust and signal that the content is actively maintained.

Thank you in advance.


- Raised to 50k.
- Removed the limitation for editing posts.
- Edit log is already a thing in XenForo itself, when you edit your message, "History" button will appear.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top